Billing is where a platform decision shows up in the practice every day, usually on the busiest desk in the office. This page gives Fort Lee practices testable criteria for comparing athenahealth and eClinicalWorks billing, with no performance numbers and no declared winner.
Compare billing by following one claim from the visit note to the payer response and the patient statement, in each platform, using your own payers. Ask where charge capture, claim edits and denial work live, and whether billing is one product or two. Qventive Healthcare helps Fort Lee practices run that test before they decide.

A clinical demo is easy to enjoy. A billing demo is easy to skip. Yet the revenue cycle is where a platform change creates the most visible disruption, because late or rejected claims show up as a cash flow problem within weeks. If your biller isn’t in the room, you are scoring half of the product.
We also want to be clear about what this page won’t do. It does not compare collection rates, clean claim rates or days in accounts receivable, because we can’t verify any of those figures independently for either vendor, and vendor-published numbers are marketing, not evidence. What we can do is give you a method that produces your own evidence.
Comparing athenahealth and eClinicalWorks?Walk us through your Fort Lee practice and we will help frame the decision.
athenahealth describes athenaOne as its fully-integrated EHR, medical billing and practice management, and patient engagement solution, according to the vendor. That wording suggests billing is part of the same offering, and a vendor blog describes a shared platform on one instance. eClinicalWorks states that its cloud covers the EHR and practice management solution along with the patient portal and related products.
Both descriptions point to a practice management system connected to the clinical record. They don’t tell you where the line falls between what is included in the subscription and what is an add-on or a service. They also don’t tell you what your staff does manually. Ask each vendor to draw that line on paper, product by product, for your specialty and payer mix.
Fort Lee had a 2020 Census population of 40,191, per the Bergen County census population summary. That’s a useful scale marker for the borough, but it says nothing about how your practice is paid. We have no verified data on payer mix, insured rates or patient demographics for Fort Lee, so we won’t guess at them.
Your own claims history is the better source. Pull a month of recent claims and group them by payer, by visit type and by denial reason. That list, not a borough statistic, defines what each platform has to handle well. It also gives you a concrete set of cases to hand to both vendors for a scripted test.
Give each vendor the same scripted cases and have your biller watch each one. These seven cover most of the daily work.
We’ve kept this list technology neutral on purpose. It describes jobs, not features, so it works for both platforms and for any future one.
Agree the scoring sheet before the demos. Give each test case a weight based on how much money or staff time it touches in your practice, and give each vendor the same case, the same data and the same time. Your biller scores the billing side, your administrator scores reporting, and a physician scores how much billing work lands on clinicians through prompts or documentation requirements.
Keep a column for what the vendor says it will do after go-live, separate from what it showed in the demo. A promise to build a report later is worth less than a report you saw working, and your scoring sheet should say so. If the two scores are close, the tie-breaker is usually who answers the hard question most directly, in writing, the first time you ask.
Also record what each vendor asked you. A vendor that questions your payer mix, your claim volume and your specialty rules before showing anything is learning what your billing office needs.
Every system produces denials. What differs is what happens next. Ask each vendor to show a denied claim arriving, being assigned, being corrected and being resubmitted, and then ask who can see that history later. A denial that sits in a general inbox is a different workflow from one that lands in a worklist with an owner.
Ask also what the vendor’s own staff do and what yours do. Some arrangements include vendor-run billing services, others leave everything to the practice. We make no claim about what either vendor includes in your contract, because that depends on the agreement. Get the division of labor written down, including who handles payer enrollment changes and who answers a payer’s records request.
Want the comparison pressure-tested?Share your shortlist and your biggest workflow worry.
Whether billing runs inside the same product as the EHR or connects through an interface changes your risk. Inside one product, a fix to a charge may be a single change. Across an interface, you want to know how often data syncs, what happens when a message fails, and who is told. Neither design is wrong. Each needs different questions, and our managed EHR administration page describes the ongoing configuration work either design creates.
Our practice management system overview explains the pieces in plain language, and our athenahealth and eClinicalWorks comparison hub shows where billing fits in the wider decision. For specialties with unusual billing rules, ask each vendor for a named reference practice in your field that your biller can call, and make the call yourself.
HHS says the HIPAA right of access covers protected health information in designated record sets, and that these include medical, billing, payment and claims records, including those held by business associates for the covered entity. You can read the HHS access FAQ. For a platform comparison, that means a patient’s request for their records may touch billing data as well as clinical data.
Ask each vendor how a records request that includes billing history is fulfilled, and whether your staff can do it from within the system. This is also a good point to ask your counsel how long you must keep billing records, because the New Jersey retention provision we reviewed in an unofficial Justia copy refers to treatment records, and we have not confirmed a rule for billing records.

The ONC Health IT Playbook lists workflow redesign, training and change management among implementation steps, and it says practices should revisit workflow when they add a patient portal, a health information network connection or a value-based payment model. See the Playbook. Billing is the clearest case: a new platform changes how charges, edits and denials move, so the people who do that work should help design it.
Qventive Healthcare lists athenahealth and eClinicalWorks among the platforms it supports. We can help your biller build the test claims, observe demos and document the answers. Related pages cover the cost structure comparison and what changes when a practice moves from eClinicalWorks to athenahealth, and our MIPS and MACRA consulting covers reporting alongside billing. A broader look at choosing between the platforms is on the small-practice decision page.
If you would like a second opinion on a proposal already in hand, our EHR consulting page explains how an engagement starts. We begin by listening to your billing team, because the people who live in the revenue cycle know where it hurts.
Bring your biller to the first conversation
Send us a month of recent claims grouped by payer and denial reason, and tell us what you want from a new system. We will help your Fort Lee practice turn them into a scripted billing test.
Call (201) 488-2750 or send us a message. Qventive Healthcare is at 200 Passaic Street, Hackensack, NJ 07601, and has served Northern New Jersey healthcare since 1994.
We can’t say, and we haven’t verified comparative revenue cycle performance for either vendor. Published figures from vendors are marketing claims, and results depend on specialty, payer mix and how a practice works. The fair approach is to run your own claims through both platforms in a scripted demo. That gives your biller evidence from your own world.
The vendors describe it differently, and each describes it in its own words. athenahealth calls athenaOne a fully-integrated EHR, medical billing and practice management solution, and eClinicalWorks says its cloud covers the EHR and practice management solution. Ask each vendor to show where the clinical record ends and billing begins in your configuration. Then ask what is included in the contract and what costs extra.
Your biller should watch the path from charge capture to claim edits, remittance posting, denial work and patient statements. They should also check reports, because the reports decide how easy it is to see problems early. Have them bring real cases, including a hard one. A demo that only shows clean claims proves little.
Use the same denial reasons for both vendors and ask for the full path: arrival, assignment, correction, resubmission and history. Ask who sees it and who owns it. Then ask what part the vendor’s own staff play, if any, and get that in writing. Denial workflow is as much about people and process as software.
It can, and planning is the answer. We don’t have a verified figure for how long any disruption lasts, and the research on EHR transitions is limited. A written plan covering parallel work on open claims, who handles old and new accounts, and when you review results will help. Your biller and practice administrator should help write it.
Qventive’s listed services include EHR consulting, managed EHR and practice management, implementation, MIPS and MACRA consulting and workflow optimization. We aren’t a billing company on the basis of what we’ve published, and we don’t claim to improve collections. What we can do is help you evaluate how each platform handles billing workflows and coordinate with the vendors. Ask us about scope before assuming anything.
Call Qventive Healthcare at (201) 488-2750 or send a message through our contact page. We will ask about your specialties, payers and what is hardest about billing today. Then we will plan a short scripted test you can use with each vendor. Our approach is to listen first, plan second.
This page is general information for practice leaders. It is not legal or clinical advice. Clinical content decisions belong to your physicians, and compliance questions belong with your counsel.